Leaving this course?

Lesson 1 of 5

What it covers, and why it pays so well

Environmental crime is not one offence. The FATF's 2021 study of the money it generates deals principally with forestry crime, illegal mining and waste trafficking, and builds on its 2020 report on the illegal wildlife trade. Illegal and unreported fishing belongs in the same family.

It is extremely profitable, and historically very low-risk for the offender. Four reasons, and they compound:

  • The product has a legitimate market. Timber, gold, fish, scrap metal and ore are ordinary commodities with real prices and real buyers. The criminal does not need to find a shadow market; they need to get into the normal one.
  • Penalties have been light. Environmental offences have often been treated as regulatory matters attracting fines rather than as serious organised crime, which changes the risk calculation for the people doing it.
  • Enforcement is split. Forestry, mining, fisheries, customs, environmental agencies and police each hold part of the mandate, often without a shared view, and financial investigators are rarely in the room at all.
  • The money is prosecuted even less than the crime. Where cases are brought at all they tend to concern the physical offence — the felled trees, the seized ivory, the dumped waste — rather than the proceeds. The FATF's work makes the point directly: these flows are under-investigated as money laundering.

Who commits it. Rarely a lone operator. Typically an organised network spanning a source country and a destination market, with legitimate companies at one or both ends, and almost always some corruption of the officials who issue permits, certify volumes or wave shipments through. That corruption is not incidental — in this field the paperwork is the laundering mechanism, which the next lesson explains.

Why it should matter to a financial institution regardless. The predicate offence happens in a forest, a mine or a port. The proceeds end up in bank accounts, in commodity trade finance, in property and in company structures, like any other proceeds. An institution with timber, mineral, scrap, waste or fishing exposure is financing this sector whether or not it has ever considered the question — and environmental crime is absent from a great many institutional risk assessments, which is itself the first finding.

And the harm is different in kind. A forest, a species or a watershed cannot be made whole by a later fine. That asymmetry is why recovery of the proceeds, and speed, matter more here than in almost any other predicate.

Two things sit outside that list and are worth naming.

The first is land conversion. A great deal of forest loss is not logging for timber but clearing for farmland and pasture, and the commodity that then leaves the country — cattle, soy, palm oil — is entirely lawful. There is no illegal product to trace at all: the offence was the clearing, and what an institution sees is an ordinary agricultural export. That makes it the hardest version of the problem in this whole subject, and the one least likely to appear in a typology.

The second runs the other way. Money also flows towards environmental purposes — carbon credits, offset projects, conservation finance, renewable subsidies — and money moving towards a purpose can be diverted, inflated or claimed for work never done. It is fraud rather than laundering, but it lands in the same accounts and the same trading companies.

Lesson 2 of 5

How the proceeds are laundered

One mechanism dominates, and the rest are variations on it.

Co-mingling with legitimate product. Illegal timber is mixed with legally harvested timber; illegally mined gold is mixed with legal production and refined; illegally caught fish is landed alongside a licensed catch. After the mixing point, the product is physically indistinguishable and the paperwork covers the whole consignment. The laundering happens in the supply chain, before the money moves at all — and what reaches the bank is a payment for a lawful-looking commodity shipment.

Permits, certificates and the legitimising document. A licence to extract a certain volume, a certificate of origin, a phytosanitary certificate, an export permit. Obtained by corruption, forged, or genuine but over-used, these documents turn illegal product into legal product on paper. Patterns that recur: volumes exported far exceeding what a concession could produce; permits issued for areas where extraction is not physically occurring; and one valid permit covering repeated shipments.

Front and shell companies in the trade chain. Exporters, traders and logistics companies, sometimes newly formed, sometimes dormant businesses revived for the purpose, frequently with nominee ownership and layered across jurisdictions. These give the proceeds a commercial identity and an invoice.

Trade-based techniques. Mis-declaration of species, grade, quality or volume; under-invoicing to move value to the buyer or over-invoicing to move it to the seller; and declaration of a protected species under the name of an unprotected one. Everything in trade-based money laundering applies, with the added difficulty that verifying a species or an ore grade from a document is beyond most institutions.

Gold, which is both commodity and instrument. Gold is unusually useful: high value for its weight, easily transported, meltable so that origin is destroyed, and tradeable for cash almost anywhere. It appears both as the proceeds of illegal mining and as a laundering vehicle for other crimes, which is why flows through refiners, dealers and bullion traders deserve particular attention.

Cash at the source, formal finance at the destination. Extraction is paid in cash — to miners, loggers, crews, intermediaries and officials — in regions where banking is thin. By the time value reaches the destination market it is a commercial payment between companies. The transition point, usually an aggregator or exporter in the source country, is where the two systems meet and where a local institution may be the only one positioned to see anything.

Free trade zones and transit. Goods passing through zones with lighter documentary scrutiny can be re-labelled, re-packed and re-exported with a new apparent origin. The FATF has documented the money laundering vulnerabilities of free trade zones separately, and they apply directly here.

Lesson 3 of 5

Why financial institutions miss it

Not negligence. A set of structural reasons, each of which can be addressed once it is named.

It looks exactly like trade finance, because it is trade finance. A letter of credit for a timber shipment, a payment for a consignment of ore, an invoice from a fish exporter. The transaction is ordinary; what is wrong with it happened in a forest two months earlier and several thousand kilometres away.

The documents are the control, and the documents are compromised. Institutional practice is to check that documents are present, consistent and from a plausible authority. When the laundering mechanism is a genuine-looking permit, document checking confirms the fraud rather than detecting it. Treating a permit as a claim to be tested rather than as evidence is a different posture, and it is rarely how trade operations are set up.

The predicate is upstream and invisible. No transaction crosses an institution's records at the moment a tree is felled or a species is taken. The first financial event is often the payment for an export, several steps later, with every intervening participant looking commercially normal.

It is not in the risk assessment. Many institutions' money laundering risk assessments name fraud, drugs, corruption and tax evasion, and omit environmental crime entirely. A risk that is not in the assessment produces no scenarios, no training, no typologies and no alerts — so the absence of reports is read as the absence of risk, which is circular.

Geography misleads. Proceeds frequently move through, and settle in, jurisdictions with no forests, no mines and no fishing industry. An institution in a destination market may see only clean-looking payments between trading companies, while the institution nearest the extraction is small, under-resourced, and may be banking the very intermediaries involved.

The crime is not treated as serious. Where environmental offences carry light penalties and are not pursued as predicates, the whole apparatus downstream — reporting, investigation, confiscation — gets weak signals about whether this matters. The FATF's central recommendation on this topic is essentially that countries and institutions should start treating these flows with the seriousness given to other organised crime proceeds.

One more honest difficulty. Verifying the substance is genuinely hard. Nobody in a bank can tell one hardwood from another, or assay an ore sample. What an institution can do is test coherence: does the volume make sense, does the counterparty have the capacity, does the route make commercial sense, is the price plausible. That is a documentary and quantitative question, and it is answerable.

Lesson 4 of 5

Indicators, and where to look for them

Know your exposure first. Sectors where this risk concentrates: timber and wood products; mining, ore trading and gold refining or dealing; scrap metal and waste management, including exporters of waste for recycling; fishing and seafood processing; and logistics, freight forwarding and customs broking serving any of these. Also relevant: businesses adjacent to the wildlife trade, including some pet, traditional medicine and luxury goods traders.

Documentary and quantitative indicators — the strongest group, because they can be tested:

  • Export volumes exceeding the plausible capacity of the stated concession, licence area, vessel or facility.
  • A single permit, licence or certificate appearing across multiple shipments or periods.
  • Species, grade, quality or tariff classification inconsistent between invoice, packing list, permit and customs declaration.
  • Certificates issued by an authority with no apparent jurisdiction over the stated origin.
  • Shipment routes that make no commercial sense, particularly transit through a zone where re-labelling is possible.
  • Prices materially away from market benchmarks in either direction for a commodity that has a published price.

Counterparty and corporate indicators:

  • A newly incorporated or recently revived exporter handling large volumes immediately.
  • Nominee ownership, or a structure layered across jurisdictions with no connection to the resource or the market.
  • A trading company whose directors or owners are connected to the officials who issue extraction or export permits — the overlap with politically exposed person risk.
  • A counterparty whose stated business does not match its payment behaviour, such as a general trading company whose flows are entirely one commodity.

Payment indicators:

  • Payments to intermediaries in extraction regions rather than to the stated exporter.
  • Large cash activity in source-country operations inconsistent with declared payroll or production.
  • Receipts from many unrelated buyers in destination markets settling into one account.
  • Gold or precious metal flows involving dealers or refiners with opaque sourcing.

The discipline, as ever. None of these is a conclusion. The question to put is whether the quantities, the capacity and the route cohere, and the single most productive enquiry in this field is capacity: can this concession, this vessel, this facility actually produce what is being sold? That question is answerable from open sources far more often than people expect, because extraction is licensed, mapped and frequently published, and because specialist organisations publish concession and vessel data precisely so that it can be checked.

And look beyond payments, to the balance sheet. The indicators above are all transactional, which quietly assumes the institution's exposure is to payments. Often it is not.

A term loan to a concession holder, trade finance facilities for an exporter, a working-capital line to a mine or a processing plant, an equity or fund position in any of them: in each case the institution is financing the activity, and no suspicious transaction will ever appear, because nothing unusual passes through. The exposure is in credit and investment, where the due diligence is commercial rather than financial-crime, and where the two functions rarely compare notes.

The capacity question belongs in credit assessment for these sectors as much as in trade operations. A borrower whose projected output exceeds what its licence permits is both a financial-crime concern and, on its own terms, a bad credit.

Lesson 5 of 5

What to do, and why recovery matters more here

Put it in the risk assessment, by name. The single structural fix. Environmental crime should appear as a predicate in the institutional risk assessment, with the sectors above identified as exposure. Everything else follows from that: scenarios, training, typologies, and the ability to recognise a report when one is warranted.

Treat permits as claims. A permit, licence or certificate is an assertion by someone that something is lawful. Where it is the only thing standing between illegal and legal product, it deserves the scrutiny given to any other single point of failure: who issued it, for what volume, over what period, and does the activity it describes fit what is being shipped.

Ask the capacity question. Build it into trade operations for the exposed sectors. Volume against licensed capacity, catch against vessel and quota, production against mine or facility scale. It is arithmetic, it is documentary, and it does not require anyone to identify a timber species.

Use the open sources. Concession maps and registers, vessel tracking and registries, customs trade statistics that allow one country's declared exports to be compared with another's declared imports, and the published work of specialist organisations. The asymmetry here is unusually favourable: a great deal of the relevant information is public, and almost none of it is in any bank's systems.

Cooperate beyond the usual circle. Environmental, forestry, fisheries and mining regulators hold the licensing data, and in most countries they have no routine channel to financial institutions or even to the financial intelligence unit. Where such a channel exists, use it; where it does not, that absence is worth raising, because it is one of the recurring findings in this field.

Write reports that name the predicate. A report saying "unusual trade payments" will be read as possible trade mis-invoicing. A report saying "we believe the volumes exceed the concession's capacity and the permit has been re-used, consistent with proceeds of forestry crime" sends an analyst somewhere specific and makes the flow visible in national statistics — which is how a national risk assessment comes to include it.

And why speed and recovery matter more. In most predicates, money recovered later still compensates somebody. Here the forest is gone, the species is diminished and the river is poisoned, and no confiscation reverses it. That gives two practical priorities: acting while the flow is live rather than after a case concludes, and pursuing the proceeds and the instrumentalities with the seriousness set out in the FATF's work on confiscation and asset recovery. The money is also, frequently, the only part of the crime that is still within reach.

Knowledge check

Twenty questions

Answer all twenty questions, then check your answers. You need 18 out of 20 to pass and receive a certificate. If you score less, you will see which answers were right and wrong, and then go through the course again before you retake the check. Your answers, progress and times are kept only in this browser.

Standards and frameworks covered

The published frameworks this course teaches toward. Saolix is not affiliated with, endorsed by or accredited by any of these bodies; naming a standard is a citation, not a claim about its author.

Sources

The official documents this course relies on. Laws and guidance change, so check the current version.

  1. Money Laundering from Environmental Crime (June 2021) · Financial Action Task Force
  2. Money Laundering and the Illegal Wildlife Trade (June 2020) · Financial Action Task Force
  3. The FATF Recommendations (Recommendations 1, 3, 4, 20 and 30) · Financial Action Task Force
  4. Trade Based Money Laundering (2006) · Financial Action Task Force
  5. Money Laundering Vulnerabilities of Free Trade Zones · Financial Action Task Force
  6. Best Practices on Confiscation and a Framework for Ongoing Work on Asset Recovery · Financial Action Task Force
  7. Concealment of Beneficial Ownership (joint FATF and Egmont Group study) · Egmont Group
  8. Guidance for a Risk-Based Approach for the Banking Sector · Financial Action Task Force
  9. Methodology for Assessing Technical Compliance and the Effectiveness of AML/CFT Systems · Financial Action Task Force